Chapter 3 - CritiqueChapter 4 - Contact and Moored Influence Mines: The German EM (Einheitsmine) Mine Series
GERMAN UNDERWATERS ORDNANCE MINES
Chapter 3 - CRITIQUE
TECHNICAL DEVELOPMENT

Despite the fact that the first German magnetic mine unit was ready for operational in 1942, at the outbreak of the war in September 1939, insufficient stocks of magnetic mines were on hand to wage an all-out and effective mining campaign against England and her Allies. This shortage existed because the war came at a time when the Navy was still engaged in improving existing operational models and had not, as yet, gone into mass production. The existing stocks of magnetic mines were very small. They consisted of approximately six hundred LMA's and LMB's and several hundred RMA's and RMB's.

The German technical development of mine firing system fall into three stages. The first, the period from October 1939 to the Summer of 1941, was one of significant inno-vations. It saw the introduction of the magnetic mine with its successive modifications, followed by the rush development of the audic frequency acoustic and the combined magnetic-acoustic mines.

The German Navy expected the magnetic mine to suffice for the war, but within a year the British were applying successful countermeasures. The Navy placed the blame for this upon the Luftwaffe, which in 1939 laid the mines in the Thames estuary before enough were available for a heavy attack. The Navy felt that these were far more likely to be recovered than ship-laid or submarine-laid mines, which might safely be laid in small numbers.

Even before the British negated the effect of the magnetic mine, the German Navy began the rush development of the audio frequency acoustic and combined magnetic-acoustic mines. As a result, they were actually producing acoustic mines in small num-bers within three months after the out-break of the war. Quickly they overcame the operational limiations of the first models, and proceeded in 1941 to develop a combined magnetic-acoustic mine. Once more the Luftwaffe stultified the effect through premature laying.

By the end of the period the effectivness of the magnetic mine had seriously diminis-hed. The Germans began, as the basic for a policy of technical surprise, a systematic study of ships influence fields.

The second period, from the introduction of the magnetic-acoustic mine in the Sum-mer of 1941, to the end of 1943, was one of steady research but no essential novelties. In April 1942, the German Navy had approximately 50,000 mines of all types ready for operational use. Through 1942 the monthly demand for mines was extremely low and at a constant level. Subsequently, as Allied action became more aggressive, especially in the Mediterranean, the demand accelerated. Ironically, now that no new weapon were com-ing out and successful countermeasure for the old ones were in operation, the Luftwaffe took mining more seriously and put forward its biggest minelaying effort.

During the third period, from the beginning of 1944 to the end of the war, the desing work of the previous two and a half years bore fruit. The pressure, the low-frequency acoustic and variants of the audio frequency circuits came into service, and the Navy had under developemt a wide varity of other weapons. From 1940 on, the Allied had stu-died the technical problem involved in countering many of this weapons; but their use would, none the  less, have been very unwelcome.

The Germans had developed not only new types but also new techniques. Since no single mine is insurmountable, the weapon was the minefield, not the individual mine. Mine warfare operated on the principle of statistics. At the same time that German mines were becoming inereasingly complecated in firing principles, first the Luftwaffe and sub-sequently the Navy, late in the war, arrived at the general policy of laying mixed fields. These greatly increased the problem of sweeping.

The demand for mines reached its peak in the invasion year, 1944. By then the Naval High Command appreciated the value of mine warfare, but was forced to cut orders to conform with the maximum possible production. At the same time, the laying capacity of the Luftwaffe declined heavily as a result of the German reverses on all fronts. This took the sting out of the new armory of mines. E-boats, and other naval craft took over the mining offensive in the last stages of the war, but their scale of operations was necessa-rily small.

The Allied were fortunate that, very much at in the case of German submarines and torpedos, the bomber position was not in phase with the weapon position. If the Luft-waffe had negained its offensive power, the Allied mine defense would have deteriorated.

Figure 3 – Graph of Mine Laid.

Figure 4 – Mines Laid.

Year

Month

EMC

FMB

FMC

UMA

UMB

OMA/K

BMC/S

EMS

RMA

RMB

TMB I/II

TMB III

TMC I

TMC II

KMB

LMA/S

LMB/S

BMA II

EMF

LMF/S

SMA

Total

1943

10

1140

64

305

6

1324

 

 

4

 

 

60

 

8

 

 

 

403

 

497

50

95

3956

 

11

328

 

53

 

679

 

 

3

 

166

178

 

80

 

 

 

94

 

907

 

27

2515

 

12

1536

 

 

330

574

 

 

5

37

47

30

 

 

 

 

150

937

 

192

 

 

3888

1944

1

885

11

 

 

284

 

 

 

3

40

 

 

129

 

 

 

180

 

 

28

 

1560

 

2

1184

 

 

44

549

 

26

 

 

 

117

 

 

 

 

 

191

 

247

 

 

2358

 

3

1678

 

 

 

126

 

 

 

22

24

8

 

 

 

 

 

63

246

 

 

 

2167

 

4

1074

 

 

186

499

 

21

5

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

752

 

1095

 

30

3602

 

5

2008

16

 

73

1341

 

63

 

 

140

45

 

 

 

 

194

642

 

66

36

 

4854

 

6

1429

 

54

34

1728

 

364

 

174

83

70

 

 

 

 

310

1846

 

253

200

28

6572

 

7

73

 

 

234

937

 

156

 

1

27

44

 

 

 

 

 

1117

7

1015

 

1

3612

 

8

1541

 

 

850

838

 

180

15

163

129

99

 

1

60

1

70

874

 

158

130

 

5107

 

9

767

 

 

510

506

 

150

26

57

199

433

 

98

 

 

364

2183

 

429

100

51

5972

 

10

3485

 

8

830

2105

 

 

19

27

598

57

8

20

 

16

77

1917

1

1697

 

173

11016

 

11

1514

 

 

86

593

 

1

5

24

 

58

12

47

15

10

 

1056

 

148

 

66

3635

 

12

1135

 

 

84

694

 

 

 

201

 

158

 

 

 

1041

 

950

 

245

 

 

4508

1945

1

830

 

 

 

329

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

29

 

194

94

557

 

 

2033

 

2

664

 

 

1

559

100

 

1

 

 

 

 

40

6

1002

1

367

91

64

 

 

2895

 

3

1269

 

 

497

500

 

 

 

50

 

19

90

155

12

14

 

532

 

 

 

 

3136

TOTAL NUMBER OF MINES LAID PRIOR TO OCTOBER, 1943

Year

Month

Total

Year

Month

Total

Year

Month

Total

1942

3

5400 1942

9

3700 1943

3

6600
 

4

3800  

10

3500  

4

5600
 

5

5500  

11

2800  

5

6800
 

6

5300  

12

1700  

6

6300
 

7

6000 1943

1

2300  

7

5200
 

8

5400  

2

2500  

8

5800

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

9

5400

Chapter 2: The German Mine OrganizationChapter 4 - Contact and Moored Influence Mines: The German EM (Einheitsmine) Mine Series